Reviews

Review: Now You See Me Live Lacks the Magic of Broadway

The movie-inspired illusion show is running at the Al Hirschfeld Theatre. 

Francisco Mendoza

Francisco Mendoza

| Broadway |

November 18, 2026

Matthew Pomeroy, Darcy Oake, Eden Choi, Gabriella Lester, and James More appear in Now You See Me Live at the Al Hirschfeld Theatre on Broadway.
(© Jeremy Daniel)

When I was in elementary school, a classmate brought the Jumanji board game to recess. Initially, I was eager to play it, since the movie was one of my favorites—but after a few rounds, I was put off. Seven-year-old me could not settle for skipping a turn or pulling a card when the movie promised players getting sucked into the jungle and stampedes roaring through the living room at the roll of the dice. Some things, child me concluded, should not exist in real life. 

The opposite could be said of the Now You See Me movie franchise. Revolving around a terribly complicated heist plot, the true point of the movie is to watch professional magicians doing a bunch of tricks. This does not work well on screen, because the whole point of magic is to see the magician do something incredible in person and not be able to figure out how they did it. In a movie, the answer is always the same: special effects. To put the franchise on stage—as the producers of Now You See Me Live, currently running at the Al Hirschfeld Theatre, have done—would, then, seem like a smart move. 

I’m not clear why it carries that name, though; it’s certainly not an adaptation, a sequel, or a spinoff.  Like the movie, the show involves four magicians—Gabriella Lester, James More, Darcy Oake, and Matthew Pomeroy—who refer to themselves by the moniker “The Four Horsemen.” But that’s where the similarities end.  

Darcy Oake performs an escape act in Now You See Me Live at the Al Hirschfeld Theatre on Broadway.
(© Jeremy Daniel)

The show has no story to speak of; there is no connection between the acts, let alone with the movie, which is mentioned in passing a couple of times. So why use the Now You See Me name in what is basically an episode of America’s Got Talent? The audience around me was made up primarily of families and tourists, all of whom seemed to get the assignment much faster than I did: sit back, watch some magic, and stop asking questions. 

The results, I’m sad to say, were hit-or-miss. I gasped once, when Oake put a live scorpion in his mouth and taped it shut; I also cried out “no way” a couple of times, at the delightful teletransportations engineered by More. But just as often, I could tell how the tricks were being done, down to the last one, which is supposed to be a showstopper, but whose mechanics I learned from a clever classmate right around the time that I encountered that Jumanji board game. 

All that was left was the grace of each performance, which varied greatly. More was the only one that truly challenged my belief. Lester, whose most impressive trick was a costume change right at the beginning, over-relied on projections that triggered my motion sickness without actually amounting to illusions. Meanwhilewhile, all of Oake’s tricks were uncomfortably quasi-sexual, involving some sort of bodily torture (even with a scorpion inside him, he selected an audience member to slap him in the face while he escaped handcuffs). Pomeroy, acting as an emcee of sorts, offered a charming stage presence that was more engaging than his tricks, which suffer from predictability. 

Eden Choi appears as a special guest star in Now You See Me Live at the Al Hirschfeld Theatre on Broadway.
(© Jeremy Daniel)

An appearance by special guest Eden Choi offered a change of pace. Making things appear and levitate around him in a beautiful choreography, Choi seemed to be performing for himself, allowing us a peek into his rich inner world. Perhaps the magic has never been about the tricks themselves, but the psychological bond that forms between a performer and their audience, an “I will deceive you, and you will believe me” pact that cannot be replicated by Hollywood tie-ins and branded merch. But try filling a Broadway theater with that promise. 

Are we too jaded for something like this to work? After all, the Now You See Me franchise itself devotes a lot of screen time to explaining how tricks are done, a tacit acknowledgment that wonder is passé. Adult theatergoers can ply themselves with alcohol, but the kids around me were mostly focused on getting picked as volunteers.  When one of them was finally chosen to go up on stage, Pomeroy asked him: “There is someone who goes around the whole world delivering toys for Christmas. Can you tell us who it is?” His answer: “Amazon.”  

If Santa can’t do it anymore, I’m not sure these Horsemen can.  

Add as a preferred
source on Google

Featured In This Story

Theater News & discounts

Get the best deals and latest updates on theater and shows by signing up for TheaterMania's newsletter today!