There is nothing original, festive, or surprising about this “New Holiday Surprise” at the Lunt-Fontanne.

The Blue Man Group has a new holiday surprise in store for us. Or, at least, they say they do. They put it right in the title of their Broadway debut at the Lunt-Fontanne Theatre: Blue Man Group “A New Holiday Surprise.”
Despite their brief exile from New York, following the closure of their show at the Astor Place Theatre after 34 years,they are still blue, still men, and a still a group. None of this is New or a Surprise.
The Blue Man Group reprise many familiar elements of their long-running shenani-ganza. The trio of Blue Men spit paint at spinning blank canvases. The paint is red and green. (Holiday!) They select Christmas tree ornaments, which turn out to be marshmallows. They hurl these marshmallows across the stage into each other’s mouths. (Holiday!) Most famously, they drum on PVC pipes, including an instrument of their own invention called a drumbone. They eventually play a festive medley that includes “I Have a Little Dreidel.” (Jewish Holiday!) At one point, they even decapitate a demonic Elf on the Shelf. With all this Holiday, it’s no wonder they run out of time for New and Surprise.
Full disclosure: I am, in fact, scared of Blue Man Group. I had never seen them live before, but I believe they can sense my quiet terror as they prowl the aisles, their unblinking reptilian gazes erecting fresh lifelong phobias in my psyche. The not-entirely-voluntary audience participation that so terrifies me includes sticking a camera into an unsuspecting person’s mouth. The victim in question, sitting directly in front of me, complained loudly about this after the show. Clearly, he was not a plant. For him, it was indeed New and Surprise but not remotely Holiday.
In several moments, all three Blue Men go into the audience to play games or something of that nature while a camera projects their activity onto a fireplace. I cannot say for sure exactly what they are doing out there, however. For several minutes, the audience watches what appears to be blurry security footage; those in the mezzanine probably can’t see anything at all. This part of the show is Declining International Franchise, which is different than New Holiday Surprise.
In what may be termed “plot,” a narrator voice delivering 1950s-style Christmas advertisements on a black and white television grows angrier as the show goes on, barking that “Bigger is better!” and “You need more!” But the Blue Men pull the plug to silence him. They’re just the same old downtown Blue Man Group, scrappy and low budget, right? They play more songs on tubes to demonstrate this. But this is a fake out: they do, in fact, go bigger, closing the show by bombarding the audience with big bouncy balls, endless reams of toilet paper streamers, and, of course, lots of falling snow. They do not make a Broadway-sized entertainment, but they do make a Broadway-sized mess. You can’t help but thinking of the cleaning crew tasked with picking up after them. Surprise!
At one point, two women from the audience are brought onstage and instructed to draw whiteboard portraits of a Blue Man posing for them in an open robe. He is then revealed to be wearing a wreath over his crotch. This, I fear, is the actual New Holiday Surprise.