TheaterMania’s Holiday Gift Guide

Get your holiday shopping done with these suggestions from TheaterMania. (Prices and availability subject to change.)

Apparel

Mormon Maggot Boxers

Standard white boxers featuring "I have maggots in my scrotum" on the back and The Book of Mormon logo on the front.

Cast Recordings

Rise Up! Hamilton: The Anthology

Rise Up! Hamilton: The Anthology is a comprehensive limited-edition box set celebrating Lin-Manuel Miranda’s hit musical Hamilton, across 7 vinyls or 5 CDs.

New American Plays

The Balusters by David Lindsay-Abaire

No one is prepared for the neighbor-versus-neighbor battle royale that ensues when a newcomer makes an inconceivable suggestion: a stop sign, perched on the enclave’s most picturesque block.

Theater on Film

Next to Normal (DVD)

Filmed live in the West End, starring Caissie Levy, Jamie Parker, Jack Wolfe, Eleanor Worthington-Cox, Trevor Dion-Nichols and Jack Ofrecio this production was nominated for four Olivier Awards, including Best New Musical.

Cast Recordings

Outsiders Gold Cast Album Vinyl

Stay gold with this 2-LP gold vinyl pressing of the original Broadway cast recording of The Outsiders. Includes a book with lyrics and photos.

Cast Recordings

Boop! the Musical Original Cast Recording Vinyl

This dazzling 2 LP vinyl pressing features all your favorite songs, including "A Little Versatility", "Where I Wanna Be", "I Speak Jazz," and many more, along with a booklet featuring photos from the Broadway production.

New American Plays

Bark of Millions by Taylor Mac and Matt Ray

The rock opera Bark of Millions is an incomparable celebration of queerness, and here from its award-winning creators Taylor Mac and Matt Ray is the experience in book form, including lyrics and music for 50 of the show's songs.

New American Plays

The Michaels by Richard Nelson

A double volume that features the final installments from Tony Award-winning playwright and director Richard Nelson’s critically acclaimed Rhinebeck Panorama.

Apparel

Outsiders Unisex Patch Hoodie

You won't have to travel far away from Tulsa to rep Greasers all over the world in this hoodie featuring The Outsiders logo, along with screen-printed patch designs inspired by songs from the show.

Theater on Film

Titanic The Musical [Blu-ray]

From composer Maury Yeston, five-time Tony Award® winner Titanic The Musical recounts the hopes, dreams and aspirations of all on board her fateful maiden voyage. From the ship's owner, her builder, the millionaire first class passengers to the third class dreaming of a new life in America. This stunning and stirring production is 'Breathtaking' (The Guardian) and 'Magnificent' (The Telegraph).

Theater on Film

Anything Goes [Blu-ray]

As the S.S. American heads to sea, etiquette and convention head out the portholes as two unlikely pairs set a course to true love. But destiny needs a little help from singing sailors, comical disguises and good old-fashioned blackmail. Directed by Kathleen Marshall, this production of Cole Porter's classic musical comedy, features Sutton Foster, Robert Lindsay, Felicity Kendal and Gary Wilmot.

Theater on Film

An American In Paris [Blu-ray]

Featuring the gorgeous music and lyrics of George and Ira Gershwin, An American in Paris, starring Robert Fairchild and Leanne Cope, tells the impassioned story of art, friendship and love between American GI, Jerry Mulligan, and Lise, a beautiful young dancer in the 'City of Light'.

Theater on Film

Hadestown: The Musical [Blu-ray]

ollowing two intertwining love stories — that of young dreamers Orpheus and Eurydice, and that of King Hades and his wife Persephone — Hadestown: The Musical  invites audiences on a hell-raising journey to the underworld and back.

Theater on Film

Hamilton - 4K + Blu-ray

The filmed version of the original Broadway smash hit “Hamilton” combines the best elements of live theater, film and streaming in an astounding blend of hip-hop, jazz, R&B and Broadway. Presenting the tale of American founding father Alexander Hamilton, this revolutionary moment in theater is the story of America then, told by America now.

Theater on Film

Waitress: The Musical [Blu-ray]

The Tony-nominated Broadway phenomenon comes to the big screen. Composer-lyricist Sara Bareilles is Jenna Hunterson, a waitress and expert pie maker stuck in a small town and a loveless marriage. When a baking contest offers her a chance at escape, Jenna fights to reclaim part of herself. Waitress celebrates the power of friendship, dreams, the family we choose and the beauty of a well-baked pie.

Theater on Film

The SpongeBob Musical: Live on Stage!

SpongeBob and all of Bikini Bottom face catastrophe – until a most unexpected hero rises to take center stage. THE SPONGEBOB MUSICAL: LIVE ON STAGE! is a theatrical party full of heart and humor, where the power of optimism really can save the world. DVD includes an exclusive, extended sing-along version!

Theater on Film

The Prince Of Egypt - The Musical

Based on the classic DreamWorks Animation film and featuring Stephen Schwartz's miraculous music (Time Out) including his Academy Award-winning song 'When You Believe' and Sean Cheesman's astonishing choreography (The Guardian), this epic, critically acclaimed production with an original London cast and orchestra of more than 60 artists tells an inspiring tale of resilience and hope.

Movies

New York, New York (Collector's Edition) [4K Ultra HD]

This collector's edition presents the expanded cut of New York, New York newly restored from a 16-bit 4K scan of the original camera negative, showcased in 2160p Ultra HD with HDR in its original 1.66:1 aspect ratio. The release features both DTS-HD 5.1 surround and LPCM 2.0 stereo audio options, along with optional English subtitles.

Movies

Little Shop of Horrors: Director's Cut & Theatrical (4KUHD + Digital)

Singing Plant. A Daring Hero. A Sweet Girl. A Demented Dentist. Seymour--an orphan and a nerd who works in a run-down flower shop on Skid Row--spends his time doing menial tasks and dreaming of his co-worker, Audrey. Then, one day, just after an eclipse of the sun, Seymour discovers a strange plant. The exotic plant draws customers, saves the flower shop from bankruptcy and makes Seymour a hero in Audrey's eyes. But the plant has a rather unique appetite...and it's getting interested in Audrey too. Based on the 1961 film and the stage musical. Includes two new bonus features, plus the Director's Cut, more deleted scenes, and commentary from Frank Oz.

Movies

Jesus Christ Superstar - 4K UHD

Jesus Christ Superstar, the bold interpretation of the hit rock opera and Broadway smash from Tim Rice and Andrew Lloyd Webber, tells the story of Christ’s (Ted Neeley) final weeks told through a series of dazzling songs, images and music. Nominated for the Best Music Adaptation Academy Award®, producer-director Norman Jewison (In the Heat of the Night, Fiddler on the Roof) creates a brilliant example of groundbreaking vision and unforgettable songs shot entirely on location in Israel.

Movies

The Pirates of Penzance - 4K UHD

Gilbert and Sullivan’s classic musical comedy of mistaken identity comes swashbuckling to the screen with all the laughs, songs and stars that made it a long-running Broadway smash! Kevin Kline reprises his Tony Award-winning role, joined by music superstars Linda Ronstadt and Rex Smith, with stage greats Angela Lansbury and George Rose, in the beloved story of a roguish pirate king and his adventurous young charge who explore the coastline in search of treasure and romance. Newly setting sail in glorious 4K, The Pirates of Penzance is a fresh, funny and colorful extravaganza that’s the very model of a modern movie musical!

Cast Recordings

Voices of the Gilded Age: The Christmas Album

The album features beloved Christmas classics and two new original songs performed by dazzling cast members from the Emmy Award-winning HBO Original Series The Gilded Age, including Ben Ahlers, Denee Benton, Christine Baranski, Carrie Coon, Jordan Donica, Audra McDonald, Brian Stokes Mitchell, Donna Murphy, Kelli O'Hara, Morgan Spector, and more.

Cast Recordings

Rent Original Broadway Cast Recording 30th Anniversary

For the first time, the Original Broadway Cast Recording of Rent comes to vinyl in celebration of the groundbreaking musical's 30th anniversary. Featuring "Another Day," "La Vie Boheme," and "Seasons of Love," this definitive 3-LP edition is mastered for vinyl by Ryan K. Smith at Sterling Sound. Its premium quad book-style gatefold incorporates archival materials celebrating Jonathan Larson's life and creative process, along with printed poly-lined sleeves and collectible ephemera. A deluxe, 24-page booklet features an all-new, nearly 20,000-word oral history of the show's songs, drawing on 19 interviews with members of the original cast and creative team.

Cast Recordings

Spring Awakening Original Cast Recording Twentieth Anniversary Edition

In honor of its 20th anniversary, the original cast recording of Spring Awakening is available on vinyl for the very first time. A groundbreaking fusion of morality, sexuality, and rock & roll, Spring Awakening electrified audiences like no other musical in years, winning eight Tony Awards, including Best Musical and launching the careers of stars Lea Michele and Jonathan Groff. Produced in collaboration with show's creators Steven Sater and Duncan Sheik, this definitive Twentieth Anniversary Edition pairs the original cast album (newly mastered for vinyl by Ryan K. Smith at Sterling Sound,) with two unheard archival recordings long sought after by fans: "All Begin to Call," a 2000 duet between Lea Michele and the late Gavin Creel, and "As Shadows Do," featuring Lauren Prichard. Also included is a deluxe 24-page booklet featuring rare photos, essays, lyrics, and an all-new oral history with the original cast and creative team. Pressed on standard black vinyl, 2LP.

Cast Recordings

The Phantom of the Opera The Andrew Lloyd Webber 2026 Mix

The Original London Cast Recording of The Phantom of the Opera is one of the most celebrated musical recordings of all time and captures the acclaimed performances of Sarah Brightman and Michael Crawford from the production that would become a global phenomenon. Forty years on, after rediscovering the original analogue tapes, Andrew Lloyd Webber has returned to the studio to remix the recording, uncovering previously unheard material and demos. The result is the most complete and immersive presentation of this iconic score ever released - The Phantom of the Opera: The Andrew Lloyd Webber 2026 Mix.

Cast Recordings

Ragtime: The Musical 2025 Broadway Cast Recording

"It was the music of something beginning..." Ragtime follows three fictional families pursuing the American Dream at the dawn of the 20th century: a black pianist and his beloved, a Jewish immigrant and his little girl, and a wealthy white family. Featuring a lush score by Tony Award winners Stephen Flaherty and Lynn Ahrens, and starring Joshua Henry, Caissie Levy, and Brandon Uranowitz, Ragtime weaves a rich tapestry that blurs the line between personal struggle and national identity. 2 CD set.

New American Plays

Confederates by Dominique Morisseau

Confederates tells the story of two women in what at first appear to be radically different circumstances. Sara is an enslaved rebel ferrying information from the plantation to Union soldiers. Sandra is a political science professor fighting the patriarchy at a predominantly white university. As the play progresses, the line between the past and present blurs, raising questions about how far we have come since 1865—and how far we still have to go.

New American Plays

Yaga by Kat Sandler

Baba Yaga is a legend, usually known as that elderly woman who lives alone in the woods and grinds the bones of the wicked. But what if she was actually a sexy, smart, modern woman operating off of morally ambiguous motives?

New American Plays

Everybody by Branden Jacobs-Jenkins

Inspired by the 15th century morality play Everyman, Branden Jacobs-Jenkins’ new work follows Everybody (played by one of five actors selected by lottery at the beginning of each performance) as he or she travels down a road toward life's greatest mystery and confronts the inevitable. An unpredictable and inventive inquiry into the ways we cope with our own mortality.

New American Plays

Well, I'll Let You Go by Bubba Weiler

Set in a small Midwestern town, Well, I'll Let You Go centers on a woman sifting through the fragments of her life. With biting humor and unexpected warmth, this singular new work captures the messiness of mourning and the surprising, life-affirming ways we find our footing again.

New American Plays

School Girls by Jocelyn Bioh

Queen Bee Paulina and her crew excitedly await the arrival of the Miss Ghana pageant recruiter. It's clear that Paulina is in top position to take the title until her place is threatened by Ericka – a beautiful and talented new transfer student. As the friendship group's status quo is upended, who will be chosen for Miss Ghana and at what cost?

New American Plays

Cold War Choir Practice by Ro Reddick

It's twilight in Ronald Reagan's America and the specter of nuclear war hangs over the country – but rent is still due on the 1st. In Cold War Choir Practice a young girl is embroiled in intrigue when her estranged uncle, a prominent Black conservative, brings his mysteriously ill wife home for the holidays.

New American Plays

Dad Don't Read This by Eliya Smith

Eliya Smith's Dad Don't Read This is a coming-of-age play about the people who know you before you know anything. A love letter to adolescence and to teenage friendship, the play was published following a sold out 2026 summer premiere in New York City.

Experiences

TheaterMania Gold

Join this exclusive ticketing club for access to some of the hottest live events in New York City, including Broadway, Off-Broadway, live music, comedy and more! As a member, enjoy FREE* or deeply discounted tickets to events all over the city, as well as access to exclusive members-only events and offers. Don't miss out on the ultimate NYC live event experience.

Experiences

27th Annual WhatsOnStage Awards

Now heading into their 27th year, the WhatsOnStage Awards are considered one of the top highlights of the theatrical calendar and are the only major theatre awards nominated and voted for by the public. They will take place at the London Palladium Sunday, February 28, 2027.

Experiences

The Broadway Cruise

The Broadway Cruise 4 returns for FIVE fabulous nights aboard Norwegian Jewel, departing Miami on April 15, 2027, for Cozumel, Mexico and Great Stirrup Cay, Bahamas. This complete ship takeover brings Broadway's brightest stars, most dazzling shows, and most dedicated fans together on the high seas!