Alaska Thunderfuck and John-Andrew Morrison send American history off the rails in LA.

Cole Escola’s Oh, Mary! is more than a theatrical performance—it’s an event. Everyone has heard the hype, and it’s every bit as nutso hilarious as you’ve been told. The tasty pickle on the ice cream is Alaska Thunderfuck’s uproarious turn.
The 16th President of the United States (John-Andrew Morrison) is trapped in a civil war … with his wife, Mary Todd Lincoln (Thunderfuck). Although there’s another big war going on between the North and the South, none of those battles are as exhausting as those with Lincoln’s lush of a wife, who hides alcohol around the Oval Office and whines about abandoning her burgeoning career as a cabaret singer to lead a dull life in the White House. To keep her distracted, Mary’s husband hires an acting teacher (Wesley Taylor) so she can indulge her whims. But a spark ignites between the blowsy Mary and the sexy teacher that will inflame an entire nation.
Escola’s comedy is designed to break your brain as it shatters American’s beloved idols to pieces. The script veers in directions that seem unthinkable yet follow their own twisted logic. Every character is driven by a desperate need and the lust to satisfy it, which sets the play apart from parodies whose characters are merely joke machines.

Director Sam Pinkleton directs his actors to take things to their absurdist limits. Thunderfuck, known for her time on RuPaul’s Drag Race, commands every inch of the stage. Her wide eyes, arched eyelashes, and severe cheeks, combined with the exaggerated gestures, make her appear gloriously unhinged. But she still manages touch our hearts and show off a melodic singing voice.
Morrison is ridiculously pompous as the buffoonish president, and Taylor is raffish as the cad caught between Abe and Mary. Michael Lepore has naïve charm as Lincoln’s hapless assistant, and Pooya Mohseni is delightfully coy as the not-so-sexually repressed chaperone.
Holly Pierson’s costumes are visual exaggerations of the cartoonish characters, with Mary’s enormous hoop skirt, hiding (incompletely) her flashy boxers, and the teacher’s tightly fitting pantaloons, showing off all his assets. The lighting by Cha See is gleefully bombastic, and the sets by the design collective dots appropriately look like something from the 19th century.
Pickles on ice cream shouldn’t work, yet in this case we lick the bowl clean. Oh, Mary! is a sundae of American history gone cheerfully off the rails, and it leaves us begging for one more scoop.