TheaterMania’s chief critic highlights five shows that have everyone talking.

1. Slam Frank
Inspired by a Twitter debate about Anne Frank and white privilege, Slam Frank depicts a group of woke theatermakers reimagining the Jewish diarist as Anita Franco, a queer Latinx girlboss in hiding—yes, from the Nazis, but also from her authentic self. The musical by Andrew Fox and Joel Sinensky is a brutally hilarious satire of identity politics in the theater, more irreverent of Lin-Manuel Miranda than Anne Frank. And the songs are surprisingly catchy. I cannot get Anita’s autotune riff “betta buy my book” out of my head. This show is the kick in the pants the theater desperately needed.

2. Ms. Blakk for President
The appearance of a drag queen on the floor of the 1992 Democratic National Convention was meant to have the same impact on American politics. In Ms. Blakk for President, Tarell Alvin McCraney and Tina Landau recount the story of Joan Jett Blakk, the drag performer who ran for President of the United States under the slogan “Lick Bush in ’92!” Part history play, part drag show, it presents a strange little footnote of American political history with insight and sparkle. Ato Blankson-Wood is especially worth seeing in the title role. Joan Jett Blakk is an underappreciated icon of individuality, though those who have lived through the last 34 years can argue about how effective her campaign was at changing hearts and minds.

3. Hospital Hour
Speaking of history, Rachel Kaly viscerally recalls the 2006 execution of Saddam Hussein, because it coincided with her first menstruation. That’s the subject of one of her jokes in Hospital Hour, the stand-up comedy show Kaly has built around her mental illness. She talks about meds, treatments, and hospitalizations in this one-hour routine that will have you laughing and squirming at the same time. As Pete Hempstead wrote in his review for TheaterMania, “It’s worth celebrating a comedian who dares to speak what some might say should remain unspoken.”

4. Downstate
Very few American artists would risk their careers to speak up for convicted sex offenders. With Downstate, Bruce Norris has written a play that not only dramatizes their post-prison lives in a depressing Illinois group home, but questions the currency of victimhood in contemporary American society. It also shows us how the system of authoritarian control they live under could easily be turned against us. It’s the most dangerous play on Broadway right now, with some of the best performances, which makes it a must-see.

5. Midnight
If you spend any time on TikTok, you’ve probably been urged to steer clear of Midnight, Todrick Hall’s new musical about a secret gay love affair between a plantation owner and an enslaved Black man in the waning days of the Civil War. Yes, the plot is highly problematic, but who really has time to waste on anodyne workshopped-to-death musicals that double as a sleep aid? Midnight is anything but boring: a beautifully choreographed three-hour epic starring some of the best singers in the theater telling a story that challenges contemporary assumptions around race, identity, and desire. What the TikTok critics fail to understand is that the theater doesn’t exist to reinforce orthodoxy; it’s a space where we can gather in person, unmediated by our screens and algorithms, to question everything.