Christian Borle's Arms Were the Stars of Peter Pan LIVE!

Allow ourselves to introduce ourselves. I’m Emmy and this is Tony.
#ChristianBorle #PeterPanLive

— ChristianBorles Arms (@ChrisBorlesArms) December 5, 2014

This tweet speaks for itself. After last night's broadcast of NBC's Peter Pan LIVE!, audiences walked away with one main talking point: how Christian Borle, Tony-winning Broadway favorite and one of the only people to have played both Captain Hook and Smee in a two-year period, quietly got so jacked that his arms became Hugh Jackman in The River levels of distracting.

Given the way this production blended live action with digital graphics (like Tinkerbell and Peter's shadow), it's no wonder why everyone was asking this question:

— Sarah Moore (@imsarahmoore) December 5, 2014

At times, Borle's Arms did face some stiff competition from a fellow Broadway star:

— Janet M. Dung (@agentdung) December 5, 2014

Even the haters saw the bright side:

— Tom Lorenzo® (@tomandlorenzo) December 5, 2014

Some people found themselves ready to convert:

— elysse navidad ☯ (@elyssifer) December 5, 2014

Here are some other thoughts on the subject:

— Kristen Brozowski (@K10Bro) December 5, 2014

In the end, it looks like Christian Borle's Arms will have a bright future:

Guess who is training LeBron tomorrow morning??
#PeterPanLive #ChristianBorle #LebronJames

— ChristianBorles Arms (@ChrisBorlesArms) December 5, 2014