The much-heralded production of Maury Yeston and Arthur Kopit’s Phantom returns to hypnotize audiences at the Gateway Playhouse. Eerily romantic and lush, this rendition of the Phantom of the Opera is the theater’s most requested show, and to some, the more stirring version. The human drama of the tragic Phantom and his Christine with mounting suspense, carries the comedy and tragedy to many a crashing climax.