My Occasion of Sin
Monica Bauer's overstuffed play feels like more of a first draft, full of intriguing ideas.
But too often she imposes a debate play onto characters that haven't been properly developed, resulting in scenes laced with arguments that come out of nowhere, and voiced by characters who speak the language of stereotypes. The final product, directed here by Frances Hill, never seems blended into an organic whole.
Some of the actors are better than others at rising above their material. Rosebud Baker, as a young, white music student named Mary Margaret, plays her role with enough humor and youthful energy that she is sorely missed when she's offstage for too long. And although it's never believable that Mary Margaret is as intelligent about jazz as she becomes in a few short months, Baker makes you willing to overlook that.
Likewise, Royce Johnson doesn't look old enough to pass as the World War II hero that many of the characters believe him to be, but he has a strong presence as Luigi, an African American jazz musician unwillingly caught up in the race riots of the late 1960s.
Johnson is even able to inject some moments of true dramatic tension into his scenes with Janice Hall, who plays Helen, the white co-owner of a local music store that she runs with her husband, George (Scott Robertson).
Danielle Renee Thompson, in perhaps the most difficult role, is Vivian, a 14-year-old African American girl who inadvertently sparks the riot at the climax of the play. Not only does she avoid the cloying habits of most adult actors who play children; at her best, her Vivian holds the stage with sass, verve, and just the right measure of innocence.