The show, co-written and directed by Paul Magid, is set at a theater where the Brothers are rehearsing their reinterpretation of Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet, in which the quartet play all of the parts. Original music, juggling, and dance are part of the show, which also includes the Brothers' reflections on their own loves, both past and present. Magid also performs in the show alongside Mark Ettinger, Rod Kimabll, and Stephen Bent.

The creative team for Flings includes choreographer Douglas Elkins, costume designer Arthur Oliver, and lighting designer David Hutson.