Bay Street Theater

Bay Street Theater
1 Bay St
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Get Directions

About

This lovely intimate theater provides audiences with unforgettable stagings of new plays, cabaret and classical music concerts. Used as a try-out venue for playwrights like Horton Foote, Paula Vogel and Terrence McNally, this popular theater attracts stars such as Richard Dreyfuss, Alec Baldwin, Cherry Jones, Diane Wiest, Kate Burton under top-flight directors such as Joe Mantello, Sidney Lumet, Jack Hofsiss.

Current Productions

Drama

The Subject Was Roses

Long Island

Performances begin: May 28, 2024

Buy Tickets
Musical

Young Frankenstein

Long Island

Performances begin: August 1, 2024

Buy Tickets

Past Productions

A Conversation with Julie Andrews

Hamptons

Closed: November 10, 2001

Cabaret

An Evening with Donna McKhechnie

Hamptons

Closed: November 17, 2001

Nobody Don’t Like Yogi

Hamptons

Closed: June 1, 2002

Concert/Event

Jason Robert Brown

Hamptons

Closed: September 28, 2002

Concert/Event

The Flaming Idiots

Hamptons

Closed: October 5, 2002

Joel Grey–The Road to Cabaret

Hamptons

Closed: October 12, 2002

High School Young Playwrights Festival

Hamptons

Closed: December 14, 2002

Family/Kids

KidStreet

Hamptons

Closed: November 29, 2003

Family/Kids

The Gizmo Guys

Hamptons

Closed: April 6, 2003

Family/Kids

Reading Rainbow, Theatreworks USA

Hamptons

Closed: May 4, 2003

Concert/Event

Bay Street Theatre Shows

Hamptons

Closed: August 30, 2003

Drama

Nobody Don’t Like Yogi

Hamptons

Closed: June 1, 2003

The Lover/
Bacchanalia

Hamptons

Closed: June 29, 2003

Comedy

Earth to Bucky

Hamptons

Closed: July 27, 2003

Family/Kids

Maria Del Rey, Stories and Songs from Latin America

Hamptons

Closed: July 24, 2003

The Boy Friend

Hamptons

Closed: August 31, 2003

Comedy

Lewis Black

Hamptons

Closed: August 11, 2003

Family/Kids

Sing-a-Long with Sesame Street with Roscoe Orman “Gordon” and Emilio Delgado “Luis”

Hamptons

Closed: August 14, 2003

Concert/Event

Anne Jackson and Eli Wallach in Tennessee Remembered

Hamptons

Closed: August 18, 2003

Family/Kids

Tom Paxton, Singer/Songwriter

Hamptons

Closed: August 21, 2003

Garland Jeffreys

Hamptons

Closed: August 25, 2003

Family/Kids

Robbo, Songs for Kids

Hamptons

Closed: August 28, 2003

Family/Kids

The Story Salad Production of Amelia Bedelia for Mayor and Other Stories

Hamptons

Closed: October 12, 2003

Circo Comedia

Hamptons

Closed: November 2, 2003

Family/Kids

Smythe and Saucier present “Circo Comedia”

Hamptons

Closed: November 2, 2003

Family/Kids

Season’s Greetings Magic Show, Theatreworks/USA

Hamptons

Closed: November 28, 2003

Family/Kids

ArtsPower’s Production of Laura Ingalls Wilder: Growing Up on the Prairie

Hamptons

Closed: November 29, 2003

Play

A Christmas Carol (Bay Street)

Hamptons

Closed: December 21, 2003

Windham Hill

Hamptons

Closed: December 27, 2003

Rough Crossing

Hamptons

Closed: July 4, 2004

Play

Auntie Mame

Hamptons

Closed: August 1, 2004

Musical

Once on This Island

Hamptons

Closed: September 5, 2004

Family/Kids

Trout Fishing in America

Hamptons

Closed: August 19, 2004

Family/Kids

Tom Chapin

Hamptons

Closed: August 26, 2004

Family/Kids

Samite

Hamptons

Closed: September 2, 2004

Family/Kids

The Rainbow Fish

Hamptons

Closed: October 10, 2004

Comedy

Kids ‘N Comedy

Hamptons

Closed: November 14, 2004

Family/Kids

Hans Brinker’s Christmas

Hamptons

Closed: November 26, 2004

Family/Kids

James and the Giant Peach

Hamptons

Closed: November 27, 2004

Play

A Christmas Carol

Hamptons

Closed: December 19, 2004

Play

Japes

Hamptons

Closed: June 5, 2005

Comedy

No Time For Comedy

Hamptons

Closed: July 3, 2005

Play

Sleuth

Hamptons

Closed: July 31, 2005

Family/Kids

Roger Day

Hamptons

Closed: July 28, 2005

Play

Pippin

Hamptons

Closed: September 4, 2005

Family/Kids

Ralph Covert

Hamptons

Closed: August 18, 2005

Family/Kids

The Gizmo Guys

Hamptons

Closed: August 25, 2005

Family/Kids

Wendy Gelsanliter

Hamptons

Closed: September 1, 2005

Family/Kids

Garry Krinsky “Toying with Science”

Hamptons

Closed: October 9, 2005

Family/Kids

Hayes Greenfield’s Jazz-A-Ma-Tazz

Hamptons

Closed: October 23, 2005

Family/Kids

Olive Dance Theatre

Hamptons

Closed: November 13, 2005

Musical

The Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe

Hamptons

Closed: November 25, 2005

Family/Kids

The Little Engine That Could Earns Her Whistle

Hamptons

Closed: November 26, 2005

Bay Street Theater’s 15th Anniversary Benefit Gala

Hamptons

Closed: March 6, 2006

Play

Quartet

Hamptons

Closed: June 4, 2006

The Readings at Bay Street Theatre

Hamptons

Closed: August 27, 2006

Musical

The Who’s Tommy

Hamptons

Closed: July 9, 2006

Cabaret

Euan Morton: Live at Bay Street

Hamptons

Closed: July 8, 2006

Play

Viva La Vida!

Hamptons

Closed: August 6, 2006

Tom Papa

Hamptons

Closed: July 24, 2006

Lisa Lampanelli

Hamptons

Closed: July 31, 2006

Play

Darwin in Malibu

Hamptons

Closed: September 3, 2006

Colin Quinn

Hamptons

Closed: August 21, 2006

Lewis Black

Hamptons

Closed: August 28, 2006

Greg Giraldo

Hamptons

Closed: September 9, 2006

Paula Poundstone

Hamptons

Closed: September 16, 2006

Judy Gold

Hamptons

Closed: September 30, 2006

Robert Wuhl

Hamptons

Closed: October 7, 2006

Comedy

Kathleen Madigan

Hamptons

Closed: October 8, 2006

Eudora

Hamptons

Closed: October 14, 2006

Play

A Midsummer Night’s Dream

Hamptons

Closed: December 14, 2006

Murder on the Orient Express

Hamptons

Closed: December 16, 2006

The Picture Show

Hamptons

Closed: March 31, 2007

Family/Kids

Cherish the Ladies

Hamptons

Closed: March 4, 2007

Family/Kids

Stone Soup and Other Stories

Hamptons

Closed: March 25, 2007

Comedy

Things Being What They Are

Hamptons

Closed: June 3, 2007

Comedy

Paula Poundstone

Hamptons

Closed: May 28, 2007

Comedy

The Night Season

Hamptons

Closed: July 1, 2007

Comedy

Tracy Morgan

Hamptons

Closed: June 18, 2007

Comedy

Jim Breuer

Hamptons

Closed: June 25, 2007

Musical

Turandot: The Rumble for the Ring

London

Closed: August 5, 2007

Comedy

Caroline Rhea

Hamptons

Closed: July 16, 2007

Comedy

Louis C.K.

Hamptons

Closed: July 23, 2007

Comedy

The Lady In Question

London

Closed: September 2, 2007

Comedy

Craig Shoemaker

Hamptons

Closed: August 20, 2007

Comedy

Lewis Black

Hamptons

Closed: August 27, 2007

Comedy

Robert Schimmel

Hamptons

Closed: September 3, 2007

Comedy

Zach Galifianakis

Hamptons

Closed: September 8, 2007

Men’s Lives

Hamptons

Closed: October 13, 2007

Family/Kids

Simeon’s Gift

London

Closed: December 2, 2007

Dilemmas with Dinner

London

Closed: January 27, 2008

Comedy

Shanghai Moon

Hamptons

Closed: June 29, 2008

Comedy

Beyond Therapy

Hamptons

Closed: July 27, 2008

Musical

Ain’t Misbehavin’

Hamptons

Closed: August 31, 2008

Comedy

Dinner

Hamptons

Closed: August 2, 2009

Ben Model

Hamptons

Closed: October 3, 2009

Bradley True & Friends Silly Science Band

Hamptons

Closed: October 11, 2009

Brady Rymer

Hamptons

Closed: November 1, 2009

Hot Peas ‘N Butter

Hamptons

Closed: November 27, 2009

Love, Noël: The Letters and Songs of Noël Coward

Hamptons

Closed: May 28, 2011

Adam & Anthony Live! In Concert!

Hamptons

Closed: June 13, 2011

Richard Belzer

Hamptons

Closed: July 2, 2011

Comedy

Betty’s Summer Vacation

Hamptons

Closed: July 31, 2011

Patton Oswalt

Hamptons

Closed: July 11, 2011

Comedy

Louie Anderson

Hamptons

Closed: July 18, 2011

Patrice O’Neal

Hamptons

Closed: July 25, 2011

Fred Armisen

Hamptons

Closed: August 6, 2011

Musical

Enter Laughing: The Musical

Hamptons

Closed: September 4, 2011

Elayne Boosler

Hamptons

Closed: August 15, 2011

Tom Papa

Hamptons

Closed: August 22, 2011

The Whiffenpoofs

Hamptons

Closed: August 26, 2011

Andrea Martin: Final Days!

Hamptons

Closed: August 29, 2011

A Hard Day’s Night

Hamptons

Closed: October 7, 2011

Legends Of Rock Volume 3

Hamptons

Closed: October 8, 2011

Help!

Hamptons

Closed: October 9, 2011

All Star Super Jazz Concert

Hamptons

Closed: November 10, 2011

Family/Kids

To Kill a Mockingbird

Hamptons

Closed: November 26, 2011

Elvis Weekend: King Creole

Hamptons

Closed: January 6, 2012

Elvis Weekend: Jailhouse Rock

Hamptons

Closed: January 7, 2012

Cabaret

Ana Gasteyer and Brian D’Arcy James: One Night, Two Voices, Three Cheers

Hamptons

Closed: May 26, 2012

My Brilliant Divorce

Hamptons

Closed: June 24, 2012

Play

Men’s Lives

Hamptons

Closed: July 29, 2012

Musical

Big Maybelle: Soul of the Blues

Hamptons

Closed: September 2, 2012

Drama

The Crucible

Hamptons

Closed: November 24, 2012

Family/Kids

Martha Speaks

Hamptons

Closed: May 11, 2013

Musical

Lend Me a Tenor

Hamptons

Closed: June 23, 2013

Comedy

The Mystery of Irma Vep

Hamptons

Closed: July 28, 2013

Comedy

A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum

Hamptons

Closed: September 1, 2013

Comedy

Paula Poundstone

Hamptons

Closed: August 19, 2013

Concert/Event

Gene Casey and The Lone Sharks

Hamptons

Closed: September 14, 2013

Concert/Event

Corky Laing

Hamptons

Closed: September 21, 2013

Betty Buckley

Hamptons

Closed: October 12, 2013

Drama

The Diary of Anne Frank

Hamptons

Closed: November 26, 2013

Festival

Hamptons Take 2 Documentary Film Festival

Hamptons

Closed: December 7, 2013

Concert/Event

Fireside Sessions with Nancy Atlas

Hamptons

Closed: February 28, 2014

Concert/Event

It Was 50 Years Ago Today…

Hamptons

Closed: February 9, 2014

Comedy

Paula Poundstone

Hamptons

Closed: May 24, 2014

Comedy

Richard Lewis Live

Hamptons

Closed: June 21, 2014

Comedy

Travesties

Hamptons

Closed: July 20, 2014

Comedy

A Divine Evening with Charles Busch!

Hamptons

Closed: July 26, 2014

Musical

My Life is a Musical

Hamptons

Closed: August 31, 2014

Comedy

Carlos Mencia

Hamptons

Closed: August 4, 2014

Reading

The Tempest

Hamptons

Closed: August 17, 2014

Stand-up/Sketch Comedy

Robert Klein

Hamptons

Closed: August 18, 2014

Stand-up/Sketch Comedy

Susie Essman

Hamptons

Closed: August 25, 2014

Drama

To Kill a Mockingbird

Hamptons

Closed: November 29, 2014

Concert/Event

Bob Dylan & The Band: A Tribute

Long Island

Closed: March 21, 2015

Festival

2nd Annual New Works Festival

Long Island

Closed: April 26, 2015

Comedy

Five Presidents

Long Island

Closed: July 26, 2015

Play

Other People’s Money

Long Island

Closed: July 26, 2015

Comedy

Grey Gardens

Long Island

Closed: August 30, 2015

Concert/Event

Folked Up Rock

Long Island

Closed: August 24, 2015

Concert/Event

An Evening With Laura Benanti

Long Island

Closed: October 10, 2015

Play

Of Mice and Men

New York City

Closed: November 28, 2015

Play

The Forgotten Woman

Long Island

Closed: June 19, 2016

Play

The Last Night of Ballyhoo

Long Island

Closed: July 24, 2016

Solo Performance

The Absolute Brightness of Leonard Pelkey

Long Island

Closed: July 24, 2016

Musical

My Fair Lady

Long Island

Closed: August 28, 2016

Play

Intimate Apparel

Long Island

Closed: July 30, 2017

Comedy

As You Like It

Long Island

Closed: September 3, 2017

Play

Windfall

Long Island

Closed: June 19, 2022

Play

All Things Equal: The Life and Trials of Ruth Bader Ginsburg

Long Island

Closed: November 27, 2022

Musical

Double Helix

Long Island

Closed: June 18, 2023

Play

Dial M for Murder

Long Island

Closed: July 23, 2023

Concert/Event

Bay Street Theatre Fall 2003

Hamptons

Closed: December 27, 2003