A testament to the power of love over the power of religion and strife, The Most Fabulous Story Ever Told follows Adam and Steve, the first couple, and Jane and Mabel, the second, through the entire Old Testament, all the way to modern-day New York. They must encounter and work through floods, promiscuous rhinos, gay pharaohs, AIDS, and lesbian rabbis. Through all of it, they must examine whether it is faith in God or faith in love that will be the center of their existence.