Having not talked for two weeks, a young married couple decides to meet in Central Park at midnight in an attempt to fix their marriage. Suddenly fate takes an unsuspecting turn leaving the man trapped on the subway with an intriguing new stranger, and the woman on a park bench in the company of a clumsy, yet charming man. As the midnight deadline fast approaches, they find themselves in the midst of a vital decision: Do they continue to wait for each other, in hopes of proving that their marriage is "meant to be?" Or do they let their odd attraction for their newfound acquaintances disprove the idea of their marriage all together? Proof by Disproof's shocking finale forces audiences to reconsider their conceptions of love.