Maxwell Caulfield gives a suave performance in this often monotonous, predictable revival of the once-popular 1960s comedy.
The slightly dopey plot follows Julian Winston (Maxwell Caulfield), a middle-aged, attractive Park Avenue dentist, who comes up with the idea of telling his much younger girlfriend Toni (doe-eyed Jenni Barber) that he is married, hoping to subdue any of her own thoughts of tying-the-knot. When Toni demands to meet his wife, Julian enlists his stiff nurse, Stephanie (Lois Robbins), to play the part.
Caulfield gives Julian a dashingly suave persona, and is perfectly suited to the role of the flirtatious dentist. As Stephanie, Robbins is unyielding -- practically to a fault -- and makes it difficult to root for the character. Barber -- adorable as she may be -- is stuck in a meatless, one-note role as the ditzy blonde.
The supporting cast provides much of the comedy, including John Herrera as Senor Sanchez, whose every mannerism and bit of dialogue are hysterical. Robin Skye's Mrs. Durant, an older patient of Dr. Winston's, is sassy and sexy, with just the right amount of inappropriateness. Anthony Reimer plays another goofy patient of the unctuous dentist, and joins the action with great physical humor and inanity at every turn.
The biggest treat of this production comes from Anna Louizos' retro, multi-purpose set, with bright boxes of color adorning every bit of the stage, right down to the tiled floor. Karen Ann Ledger's costumes would make anyone drool for the decade in which orange stripes, fluorescent colors, and electric blue dresses were the norm when it came to fashion. What could have been empty moments during set changes are joyful due to Brad Berridge's sound design, as audiences will find themselves grooving to hits from the era such as "What the World Needs Now" and "Downtown."