The show recently received six Tony Award nominations, including Best Revival of a Play, Best Director for David Grindley, and acting nods for Boyd Gaines and Stark Sands. The cast also includes Hugh Dancy, Jefferson Mays, John Ahlin, Nick Berg Barnes, John Behlmann, Justin Blanchard, Kieran Campion, John Curless, and Richard Poe; the design team includes Jonathan Fensom (scenic and costume design), Jason Taylor (lighting) and Gregory Clarke (sound).

In Theatermania's review of the production, David Finkle wrote: "Under Grindley's seasoned direction, the cast acts with the fortitude and finesse of a well-trained platoon. Dancy shows all the colors at play in patrician breeding under fire. Gaines is wise and stoic as Osborne; Mays is a reliable, obliging Mason; and Sands shines as the innocent, well-meaning Raleigh. Of the others in the polished ensemble, Ahlin is hugely likeable as Trotter and Blanchard cowers beautifully as Hibbert. "