The play, based on Paul Collins' memoir Not Even Wrong, tells the story of a couple whose marriage begins to crumble when they learn that their brilliant toddler may never master most basic forms of human connection. Goldstick is the author of the award-winning play Dinah Was, among other theatrical works, and his television cedits include Ugly Betty, Plainsong, Crossroads, and Bailey's Mistake.

The cast also includes Suzanne Ford, Marilyn Fox, Bud Leslie, Brian Letscher, Carla Obert, Jon Eric Preston, Will Rothhaar, Molly Schaffer, Katy Selverstone, and Christopher Shaw. The creative team includes Tom Buderwitz (sets), Audrey Eisner (costumes), William Wilday (lighting), and Cricket S. Myers (sound).