Paper Mill Playhouse

Paper Mill Playhouse
Brookside Drive
Millburn, 07041
Get Directions

Current Productions

We have no current productions for this theater right now.

Missing your show? Email us at listings@theatermania.com

Past Productions

Comedy

Deathtrap

North Jersey

Closed: April 2, 2000

Musical

Student Prince, The

North Jersey

Closed: May 27, 2000

Musical

Pippin

North Jersey

Closed: July 23, 2000

Musical

Anything Goes

North Jersey

Closed: October 15, 2000

Jackie Mason: Much Ado About Everything

North Jersey

Closed: October 21, 2000

Musical

Victor/Victoria

North Jersey

Closed: December 10, 2000

Cabaret

Barbara Cook

North Jersey

Closed: December 5, 2000

Comedy

Art

North Jersey

Closed: February 4, 2001

Comedy

An Ideal Husband

North Jersey

Closed: March 18, 2001

Family/Kids

Rudyard Kipling’s Just So Stories

North Jersey

Closed: March 18, 2001

Patti LuPone: Matters of the Heart

North Jersey

Closed: March 20, 2001

Musical

Funny Girl

North Jersey

Closed: May 20, 2001

Family/Kids

Peter Rabbit

North Jersey

Closed: April 8, 2001

Family/Kids

Stone Soup and Other Stories

North Jersey

Closed: April 29, 2001

Cabaret

Michael Feinstein

North Jersey

Closed: May 1, 2001

Family/Kids

Otherwise Known as Sheila the Great

North Jersey

Closed: May 20, 2001

Family/Kids

Sheila the Great

North Jersey

Closed: May 20, 2001

Musical

Carousel

North Jersey

Closed: July 15, 2001

Musical

A Chorus Line

North Jersey

Closed: October 14, 2001

Cabaret

Barbara Cook

North Jersey

Closed: September 25, 2001

Cabaret

Donna McKechnie: Inside the Music

North Jersey

Closed: October 2, 2001

Musical

Red, Hot and Blue

North Jersey

Closed: December 2, 2001

Family/Kids

Are You My Mother?

North Jersey

Closed: November 4, 2001

Cabaret

Liz Callaway and Ann Hampton Callaway: Sibling Revelry

North Jersey

Closed: November 6, 2001

Family/Kids

Cinderella

North Jersey

Closed: November 11, 2001

Family/Kids

The Big Adventures of Stuart Little

North Jersey

Closed: November 10, 2001

Cabaret

An Evening of Doo-Wop

North Jersey

Closed: November 13, 2001

Family/Kids

Snow White

North Jersey

Closed: November 18, 2001

Family/Kids

The Lion, The Witch, & The Wardrobe

North Jersey

Closed: November 25, 2001

Family/Kids

A Christmas Carol (Paper Mill)

North Jersey

Closed: December 2, 2001

Cabaret

Linda Eder Holiday Concert

North Jersey

Closed: December 5, 2001

Family/Kids

Franklin’s Big Adventure

North Jersey

Closed: December 9, 2001

Comedy

The Dinner Party

North Jersey

Closed: February 10, 2002

Play

I’m Not Rappaport

North Jersey

Closed: March 24, 2002

Cherish the Ladies – In Concert

North Jersey

Closed: March 19, 2002

Musical

The King and I

North Jersey

Closed: May 19, 2002

David Cassidy – Live in Concert

North Jersey

Closed: April 8, 2002

Family/Kids

Little Red Riding Hood & The Three Little Pigs

North Jersey

Closed: April 14, 2002

Family/Kids

The Ugly Duckling

North Jersey

Closed: April 21, 2002

Family/Kids

Pinocchio

North Jersey

Closed: April 28, 2002

Family/Kids

The Wizard of Oz

North Jersey

Closed: May 5, 2002

Family/Kids

Beauty & The Beast

North Jersey

Closed: May 12, 2002

Family/Kids

Sleeping Beauty

North Jersey

Closed: May 19, 2002

Jackie Mason: The Millennium Tour

North Jersey

Closed: May 24, 2002

Musical

My Fair Lady

North Jersey

Closed: July 21, 2002

New Voices 2002 Celebrate Lerner and Loewe

North Jersey

Closed: July 28, 2002

Musical

Miss Saigon

North Jersey

Closed: October 20, 2002

Musical

Annie (Papermill)

North Jersey

Closed: December 8, 2002

Family/Kids

Little Red Riding Hood and Other Stories

North Jersey

Closed: November 10, 2002

Family/Kids

Pippi Longstocking

North Jersey

Closed: November 17, 2002

Family/Kids

The Wizard of Oz

North Jersey

Closed: November 24, 2002

Family/Kids

A Christmas Carol

North Jersey

Closed: December 1, 2002

Family/Kids

Babes in Toyland

North Jersey

Closed: December 8, 2002

Family/Kids

Little Bear and the Enchanted Woods

North Jersey

Closed: December 15, 2002

Play

Blue

North Jersey

Closed: February 9, 2003

Romeo and Bernadette

North Jersey

Closed: March 23, 2003

Musical

Camelot

North Jersey

Closed: May 18, 2003

Cabaret

Ben Vereen

North Jersey

Closed: April 21, 2003

Grease!

North Jersey

Closed: July 20, 2003

Musical

Ain’t Misbehavin’

North Jersey

Closed: October 19, 2003

Musical

The Sound of Music

North Jersey

Closed: December 14, 2003

Comedy

The Tale of the Allergist’s Wife

North Jersey

Closed: February 8, 2004

Drama

The Chosen

North Jersey

Closed: March 21, 2004

Musical

Baby

North Jersey

Closed: May 9, 2004

Guys And Dolls

North Jersey

Closed: July 18, 2004

Musical

Of Thee I Sing (Paper Mill)

North Jersey

Closed: October 17, 2004

Comedy

She Loves Me

North Jersey

Closed: December 5, 2004

Musical

Harold & Maude: The Musical

North Jersey

Closed: February 6, 2005

Concert/Event

The Moscow Circus: “A Russian Winter’s Tale”

North Jersey

Closed: February 11, 2005

Play

The Drawer Boy

North Jersey

Closed: April 3, 2005

Play

The Baker’s Wife

North Jersey

Closed: May 22, 2005

Musical

Ragtime

North Jersey

Closed: July 17, 2005

Musical

Cinderella

North Jersey

Closed: December 4, 2005

Play

The Diary of Anne Frank

North Jersey

Closed: February 25, 2006

Musical

Carnival

North Jersey

Closed: April 9, 2006

Comedy

A Midsummer Night’s Dream (at Paper Mill Playhouse)

North Jersey

Closed: May 21, 2006

Musical

Hello, Dolly!

North Jersey

Closed: July 23, 2006

Barbara Cook and Audra McDonald in Concert

North Jersey

Closed: June 19, 2006

Godspell

North Jersey

Closed: October 22, 2006

Musical

A Wonderful Life

North Jersey

Closed: December 17, 2006

Family/Kids

Peter Pan and Wendy

North Jersey

Closed: November 19, 2006

Family/Kids

If You Give A Mouse A Cookie

North Jersey

Closed: November 26, 2006

Family/Kids

A Christmas Carol

North Jersey

Closed: December 3, 2006

Family/Kids

A Little Princess Christmas

North Jersey

Closed: December 10, 2006

Family/Kids

A Season of Miracles

North Jersey

Closed: December 17, 2006

The Nutcracker

North Jersey

Closed: December 30, 2006

Play

Summer and Smoke

North Jersey

Closed: February 11, 2007

Musical

Romance / Romance

North Jersey

Closed: April 1, 2007

Family/Kids

Ball in the House

North Jersey

Closed: March 17, 2007

Seven Brides for Seven Brothers

North Jersey

Closed: May 13, 2007

Family/Kids

The Wizard of Oz

North Jersey

Closed: April 22, 2007

Family/Kids

Patchwork (The Stories of Laura Ingalls Wilder)

North Jersey

Closed: April 29, 2007

Family/Kids

Jack and The Beanstalk

North Jersey

Closed: May 6, 2007

Family/Kids

The Rainbow Fish

North Jersey

Closed: May 13, 2007

Pirates!

London

Closed: July 8, 2007

Happy Days – The Musical

London

Closed: October 28, 2007

Family/Kids

Meet Me In St. Louis

North Jersey

Closed: December 16, 2007

Nutcracker

North Jersey

Closed: December 30, 2007

Play

The Miracle Worker

North Jersey

Closed: February 24, 2008

Play

Master Class

North Jersey

Closed: April 5, 2008

Comedy

Steel Magnolias

London

Closed: April 6, 2008

Kiss Me Kate

London

Closed: May 18, 2008

Musical

Little Shop of Horrors

London

Closed: July 6, 2008

Play

Oklahoma!

North Jersey

Closed: October 19, 2008

Play

Disney’s High School Musical

North Jersey

Closed: December 7, 2008

Play

The Importance Of Being Earnest

North Jersey

Closed: February 15, 2009

Play

Lost in Yonkers

North Jersey

Closed: March 14, 2009

Play

Master Class

North Jersey

Closed: April 5, 2009

Play

Smokey Joe’s Café

North Jersey

Closed: May 2, 2009

Play

1776.000000

North Jersey

Closed: May 17, 2009

Play

Peter Pan (Millburn)

North Jersey

Closed: June 27, 2009

Comedy

The Full Monty

North Jersey

Closed: July 12, 2009

Play

Little House On The Prairie

North Jersey

Closed: October 10, 2009

Play

On the Town

North Jersey

Closed: December 6, 2009

Musical

Irving Berlin’s White Christmas

North Jersey

Closed: December 24, 2011

Play

Boeing-Boeing

North Jersey

Closed: February 12, 2012

Musical

Damn Yankees

North Jersey

Closed: April 1, 2012

Musical

Once On This Island

North Jersey

Closed: June 24, 2012

New Voices 2012

North Jersey

Closed: August 4, 2012

Musical

A Chorus Line

North Jersey

Closed: October 28, 2012

Musical

The Sound of Music

North Jersey

Closed: December 30, 2012

Comedy

Lend Me a Tenor

North Jersey

Closed: March 10, 2013

Family/Kids

Disney’s The Little Mermaid

North Jersey

Closed: June 30, 2013

Musical

Honeymoon in Vegas

North Jersey

Closed: October 27, 2013

Musical

Oliver!

North Jersey

Closed: December 29, 2013

Musical

The Other Josh Cohen

North Jersey

Closed: March 16, 2014

Musical

South Pacific

North Jersey

Closed: May 4, 2014

Dance

Ballroom with a Twist 2

North Jersey

Closed: May 11, 2014

Musical

Grease

North Jersey

Closed: June 29, 2014

Musical

Can-Can

North Jersey

Closed: October 26, 2014

Family/Kids

Aladdin Jr.

North Jersey

Closed: November 9, 2014

Family/Kids

Elf

North Jersey

Closed: January 4, 2015

Family/Kids

Charlotte’s Web

North Jersey

Closed: December 6, 2014

Family/Kids

Click Clack Moo

North Jersey

Closed: December 7, 2014

Comedy

Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike

North Jersey

Closed: February 15, 2015

Family/Kids

The Hunchback of Notre Dame

North Jersey

Closed: March 29, 2015

Family/Kids

Skippyjon Jones

North Jersey

Closed: March 21, 2015

Family/Kids

Fly Guy & Other Stories

North Jersey

Closed: March 28, 2015

Family/Kids

The Lightning Thief

North Jersey

Closed: April 18, 2015

Family/Kids

Alexander and the Terrible Horrible No Good Very Bad Day

North Jersey

Closed: April 19, 2015

Family/Kids

Ever After

North Jersey

Closed: June 21, 2015

Family/Kids

Miss Nelson Is Missing

North Jersey

Closed: June 6, 2015

Family/Kids

Junie B. Jones

North Jersey

Closed: June 7, 2015

Family/Kids

Curious George

North Jersey

Closed: June 13, 2015

Concert/Event

New Voices of 2015: Hooray for Hollywood!

North Jersey

Closed: August 1, 2015

Musical

The Bandstand

North Jersey

Closed: November 8, 2015

Musical

A Christmas Story: The Musical

North Jersey

Closed: January 3, 2016

Musical

A Bronx Tale

North Jersey

Closed: March 6, 2016

Musical

Pump Boys and Dinettes

North Jersey

Closed: May 1, 2016

Musical

West Side Story

North Jersey

Closed: June 26, 2016

Musical

The Producers

North Jersey

Closed: October 23, 2016

Musical

The Bodyguard

North Jersey

Closed: January 1, 2017

Comedy

A Comedy of Tenors

North Jersey

Closed: February 26, 2017

Musical

Million Dollar Quartet

North Jersey

Closed: April 23, 2017

Musical

Mary Poppins

North Jersey

Closed: June 25, 2017

Musical

The Honeymooners

North Jersey

Closed: October 29, 2017

Musical

Annie

North Jersey

Closed: December 31, 2017

Comedy

The Outsider

North Jersey

Closed: February 18, 2018

Musical

The Sting

North Jersey

Closed: April 29, 2018

Musical

Half Time

North Jersey

Closed: July 1, 2018

Musical

Chasing Rainbows: The Road to Oz

North Jersey

Closed: October 27, 2019

Family/Kids

Rodgers and Hammerstein’s Cinderella

North Jersey

Closed: December 29, 2019

Concert/Event

Unmasked: The Music of Andrew Lloyd Webber

North Jersey

Closed: March 1, 2020

Musical

Sister Act

North Jersey

Closed: April 26, 2020

Musical

The Wanderer

North Jersey

Closed: June 28, 2020

Musical

Aida

North Jersey

Closed: March 7, 2021

Musical

Songs for a New World

North Jersey

Closed: November 7, 2021

Concert/Event

A Jolly Holiday: Celebrating Disney’s Broadway Hits

North Jersey

Closed: January 2, 2022

Comedy

Clue

North Jersey

Closed: February 20, 2022

Musical

The Wanderer

North Jersey

Closed: April 24, 2022

Musical

On Your Feet!

North Jersey

Closed: November 6, 2022

Musical

The Sound of Music

North Jersey

Closed: January 1, 2023

Family/Kids

Hercules

North Jersey

Closed: March 19, 2023