BayWay Arts Center

BayWay Arts Center
265 E Main St
East Islip, 11730
Get Directions

Current Productions

We have no current productions for this theater right now.

Missing your show? Email us at listings@theatermania.com

Past Productions

Comedy

Lend Me a Tenor

Long Island

Closed: November 24, 2001

Musical

Annie

Long Island

Closed: December 23, 2001

Comedy

Barefoot in the Park

Long Island

Closed: January 19, 2002

Musical

Dames at Sea

Long Island

Closed: February 23, 2002

Family/Kids

Cinderella

Long Island

Closed: March 16, 2002

Comedy

The Nerd

Long Island

Closed: March 30, 2002

Asa Diamond: The Phenomenal Art of Magic

Long Island

Closed: April 3, 2002

Musical

They’re Playing Our Song

Long Island

Closed: May 4, 2002

Swan Lake

Long Island

Closed: May 12, 2002

Comedy

Sleuth

Long Island

Closed: June 8, 2002

Musical

Always…Patsy Cline

Long Island

Closed: July 20, 2002

Comedy

Brighton Beach Memoirs

Long Island

Closed: August 24, 2002

Pack of Lies

Long Island

Closed: September 21, 2002

Family/Kids

Snow White

Long Island

Closed: October 12, 2002

Musical

Smokey Joe’s Cafe

Long Island

Closed: October 26, 2002

Family/Kids

Cinderella

Long Island

Closed: November 16, 2002

Asa Diamond: The Phenomenal Art of Magic

Long Island

Closed: November 23, 2002

Family/Kids

Frosty the Snowman (Bayway Arts Center)

Long Island

Closed: January 18, 2003

Musical

Annie (BayWay Arts Center)

Long Island

Closed: December 22, 2002

Comedy

Norman, Is That You?

Long Island

Closed: January 25, 2003

Musical

The Wizard of Oz

Long Island

Closed: February 22, 2003

Comedy

Bus Stop

Long Island

Closed: March 1, 2003

Family/Kids

Alice in Wonderland

Long Island

Closed: March 29, 2003

Musical

Jekyll & Hyde (BayWay)

Long Island

Closed: April 19, 2003

Family/Kids

Winnie the Pooh

Long Island

Closed: May 3, 2003

Family/Kids

Little Red Riding Hood (BayWay)

Long Island

Closed: June 7, 2003

Comedy

The Smell of the Kill (BayWay)

Long Island

Closed: May 31, 2003

The Music Man (Bay Way)

Long Island

Closed: July 12, 2003

Play

Biloxi Blues

Long Island

Closed: August 16, 2003

Musical

You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown

Long Island

Closed: September 7, 2003

Musical

The Fantasticks (BayWay)

Long Island

Closed: October 4, 2003

Family/Kids

Aladdin

Long Island

Closed: October 11, 2003

Play

The Wizard of Oz (Bayway)

Long Island

Closed: October 12, 2003

Family/Kids

The Mystery of Halloween High

Long Island

Closed: November 15, 2003

Voices in the Dark (BayWay)

Long Island

Closed: November 8, 2003

ASA Diamond: The Phenomenal Art of Magic

Long Island

Closed: November 22, 2003

Family/Kids

Rudolph The Red-Nosed Reindeer

Long Island

Closed: December 21, 2003

Musical

Annie (Bayway)

Long Island

Closed: December 21, 2003

Family/Kids

Frosty the Snowman (Bayway)

Long Island

Closed: January 17, 2004

Play

The Tale of the Allergist’s Wife (BayWay)

Long Island

Closed: January 25, 2004

Family/Kids

The Wizard of Oz

Long Island

Closed: February 28, 2004

My Way (Broadhollow)

Long Island

Closed: February 29, 2004

Family/Kids

Cinderella

Long Island

Closed: April 3, 2004

Musical

Oliver!

Long Island

Closed: March 21, 2004

Musical

Cabaret (BayWay)

Long Island

Closed: April 18, 2004

Family/Kids

Jack and the Beanstalk (BayWay)

Long Island

Closed: May 8, 2004

Comedy

Noises Off (BayWay)

Long Island

Closed: May 30, 2004

Family/Kids

Little Red Riding Hood

Long Island

Closed: June 12, 2004

Musical

Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat

Long Island

Closed: July 3, 2004

Musical

Seussical!

Long Island

Closed: July 25, 2004

Musical

Sugar

Long Island

Closed: August 29, 2004

Comedy

Broadway Bound

Long Island

Closed: October 3, 2004

Family/Kids

The Mystery of Halloween High

Long Island

Closed: October 30, 2004

Play

The Last Night of Ballyhoo (Bayway)

Long Island

Closed: November 7, 2004

Family/Kids

Peter Pan & Wendy

Long Island

Closed: November 27, 2004

Family/Kids

Annie

Long Island

Closed: December 19, 2004

Family/Kids

Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer

Long Island

Closed: December 19, 2004

Play

Chapter Two

Long Island

Closed: January 23, 2005

Musical

I Do! I Do! (Bayway)

Long Island

Closed: February 27, 2005

Drama

Proof

Long Island

Closed: March 26, 2005

Family/Kids

Alice in Wonderland

Long Island

Closed: April 30, 2005

Musical

Gypsy (Bayway)

Long Island

Closed: May 1, 2005

Ten Little Indians (Bayway)

Long Island

Closed: May 29, 2005

Musical

Oklahoma!

Long Island

Closed: July 31, 2005

Play

Enchanted April

Long Island

Closed: August 28, 2005

Play

Six Dance Lessons In Six Weeks

Long Island

Closed: September 25, 2005

Musical

Baby

Long Island

Closed: October 30, 2005

Family/Kids

The Mystery of Halloween High

Long Island

Closed: October 29, 2005

Comedy

Hotel Suites

Long Island

Closed: November 20, 2005

Family/Kids

Sleeping Beauty

Long Island

Closed: November 26, 2005

Family/Kids

Annie

Long Island

Closed: December 18, 2005

Comedy

The Amorous Ambassador

Long Island

Closed: January 22, 2006

The Mousetrap

Long Island

Closed: February 26, 2006

Family/Kids

The Wizard of Oz

Long Island

Closed: March 4, 2006

Musical

Man of La Mancha

Long Island

Closed: March 26, 2006

Family/Kids

Cinderella

Long Island

Closed: April 1, 2006

Play

The Diary of Anne Frank

Long Island

Closed: April 23, 2006

Family/Kids

Pinocchio

Long Island

Closed: April 29, 2006

Musical

Swing!

Long Island

Closed: May 21, 2006

Family/Kids

The Jungle Book

Long Island

Closed: May 27, 2006

Musical

Les Miserables (School Edition)

Long Island

Closed: May 28, 2006

Musical

Anything Goes (BayWay)

Long Island

Closed: July 23, 2006

Family/Kids

Cinderella

Long Island

Closed: July 29, 2006

Concert/Event

DANsing Through

Long Island

Closed: July 23, 2006

Comedy

Star-Spangled Girl

Long Island

Closed: August 13, 2006

The Bad Seed

Long Island

Closed: September 24, 2006

Musical

The Full Monty

Long Island

Closed: October 22, 2006

Play

The Graduate

Long Island

Closed: November 12, 2006

Musical

Disney’s High School Musical

Long Island

Closed: January 28, 2007

Family/Kids

Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer

Long Island

Closed: December 23, 2006

Family/Kids

Jack and the Beanstalk

Long Island

Closed: December 25, 2006

Family/Kids

Peter Pan & Wendy

Long Island

Closed: February 3, 2007

Play

To Gillian on her 37th Birthday

Long Island

Closed: February 25, 2007

Family/Kids

Cinderella (BayWay)

Long Island

Closed: March 10, 2007

Musical

Little Women

Long Island

Closed: March 25, 2007

Family/Kids

The Wizard of Oz

Long Island

Closed: April 7, 2007

Comedy

Lovers and Other Strangers

Long Island

Closed: April 22, 2007

Family/Kids

Beauty and the Beast

Long Island

Closed: May 5, 2007

Musical

The Sound of Music

Long Island

Closed: May 20, 2007

Musical

Footloose

Long Island

Closed: July 29, 2007

Musical

All Shook Up

London

Closed: August 19, 2007

Musical

Jesus Christ Superstar

London

Closed: August 17, 2007

Comedy

Rumors

London

Closed: September 30, 2007

Thoroughly Modern Millie

London

Closed: October 28, 2007

Dial M for Murder

Long Island

Closed: November 25, 2007

Family/Kids

Frosty the Snowman

Long Island

Closed: December 22, 2007

Musical

Grease

Long Island

Closed: December 30, 2007

Family/Kids

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

Long Island

Closed: January 26, 2008

Family/Kids

Cinderella (BayWay Arts Center)

Long Island

Closed: March 1, 2008

Family/Kids

Mr. Easter Bunny

Long Island

Closed: March 22, 2008

Comedy

Alone Together Again

Long Island

Closed: April 13, 2008

AH! REAL MAGIC!

Long Island

Closed: June 7, 2008

Play

The Boy Friend

Long Island

Closed: July 27, 2008

Smile

Long Island

Closed: August 5, 2008

Musical

Les Miserables – School Edition

Long Island

Closed: September 28, 2008

Comedy

Lost in Yonkers

Long Island

Closed: October 19, 2008

Family/Kids

Halloween Hassle

Long Island

Closed: October 26, 2008

Ah! Real Magic!

Long Island

Closed: November 1, 2008

Drama

Doubt

Long Island

Closed: November 30, 2008

Musical

Annie Warbucks

Long Island

Closed: December 31, 2008

Family/Kids

Frosty the Snowman (East Islip)

Long Island

Closed: December 30, 2008

Family/Kids

Peter Pan and Wendy

Long Island

Closed: January 31, 2009

Musical

Evita

Long Island

Closed: February 1, 2009

Musical

The Wedding Singer

Long Island

Closed: February 15, 2009

Family/Kids

The Wizard of Oz

Long Island

Closed: March 7, 2009

Comedy

Maggie’s Getting Married

Long Island

Closed: March 15, 2009

Musical

Something’s Afoot

Long Island

Closed: April 5, 2009

Family/Kids

Disney’s High School Musical

Long Island

Closed: May 23, 2009

Family/Kids

Seussical, Jr.

Long Island

Closed: May 23, 2009

Hercules

Long Island

Closed: May 14, 2011

The Pajama Game (East Islip)

Long Island

Closed: May 15, 2011

Ain’t Retirement Grand?!

Long Island

Closed: May 29, 2011

Bermuda Avenue Triangle

Long Island

Closed: July 10, 2011

A Chorus Line

Long Island

Closed: July 31, 2011

Musical

Ain’t Retirement Grand

Long Island

Closed: August 7, 2011

Comedy

Lend Me a Tenor

Long Island

Closed: August 28, 2011

Musical

Ain’t Retirement Grand?!

Long Island

Closed: August 28, 2011

Musical

Annie Get Your Gun

Long Island

Closed: September 25, 2011

The Manhattan Dolls

Long Island

Closed: October 2, 2011

Family/Kids

The Little Mermaid

Long Island

Closed: October 29, 2011

Sherlock Holmes, The Final Adventure

Long Island

Closed: October 30, 2011

Musical

A Grand Night For Singing

Long Island

Closed: November 20, 2011

Family/Kids

101 Dalmatians

Long Island

Closed: November 26, 2011

Family/Kids

Who Took Tom the Turkey?

Long Island

Closed: November 20, 2011

Family/Kids

Hairspray

Long Island

Closed: December 18, 2011

Family/Kids

A Charlie Brown Christmas

Long Island

Closed: December 28, 2011

Comedy

The Psychic

Long Island

Closed: January 22, 2012

Family/Kids

Pinkalicious the Musical

Long Island

Closed: February 4, 2012

Ah! Real Magic!

Long Island

Closed: January 29, 2012

Drama

Nine

Long Island

Closed: March 11, 2012

Play

Over the River and Through the Woods

Long Island

Closed: April 1, 2012

Family/Kids

Rapunzel: A Tangled Fairytale

Long Island

Closed: April 10, 2012

Family/Kids

Mr. Easter Bunny

Long Island

Closed: April 6, 2012

Comedy

Shut Up, Sit Down and Eat!

Long Island

Closed: April 15, 2012

Family/Kids

The Wizard of Oz

Long Island

Closed: May 5, 2012

Musical

Damn Yankees

Long Island

Closed: May 6, 2012

Comedy

Is There Life After Fifty?

Long Island

Closed: May 27, 2012

Concert/Event

Shut Up, Sit Down and Eat!

Long Island

Closed: June 17, 2012

Musical

Guys and Dolls

Long Island

Closed: July 15, 2012

Musical

Legally Blonde: The Musical

Long Island

Closed: August 5, 2012

Drama

Deathtrap

Long Island

Closed: September 2, 2012

Comedy

Looking

Long Island

Closed: September 23, 2012

Comedy

Cheaters

Long Island

Closed: October 14, 2012

Concert/Event

Halloween at the Addams’ House

Long Island

Closed: October 27, 2012

Comedy

Shut Up, Sit Down And Eat!

Long Island

Closed: November 11, 2012

Beehive

Long Island

Closed: November 4, 2012

Family/Kids

The Aristocats

Long Island

Closed: November 24, 2012

Comedy

The Magic of Comedy and the Spirit of Vaudeville

Long Island

Closed: November 10, 2012

Musical

42nd Street

Long Island

Closed: December 2, 2012

Family/Kids

Pocahontas

Long Island

Closed: November 18, 2012

Family/Kids

Frosty the Snowman

Long Island

Closed: December 27, 2012

Family/Kids

Alice in Wonderland

Long Island

Closed: February 2, 2013

Play

Shirley Valentine

Long Island

Closed: January 20, 2013

Play

Night Watch

Long Island

Closed: February 10, 2013

Play

I Love You, You’re Perfect, Now Change

Long Island

Closed: March 24, 2013

Family/Kids

Aladdin

Long Island

Closed: March 30, 2013

Ah, Real Magic!

Long Island

Closed: April 6, 2013

Family/Kids

Mrs. Claus Saves the Day!

Long Island

Closed: January 2, 2016

Musical

Dreamgirls

Long Island

Closed: January 17, 2016

Family/Kids

Alice in Wonderland

Long Island

Closed: January 30, 2016

Comedy

The Gingerbread Lady

Long Island

Closed: February 7, 2016

Family/Kids

A Princess Adventure

Long Island

Closed: February 28, 2016

Family/Kids

Pinocchio

Long Island

Closed: February 18, 2016

Family/Kids

Beauty and the Beast

Long Island

Closed: March 26, 2016

Family/Kids

The Little Mermaid

Long Island

Closed: March 23, 2016

Family/Kids

Jack and the Beanstalk

Long Island

Closed: April 30, 2016

Musical

White Christmas

Long Island

Closed: December 15, 2019

Family/Kids

Holiday for Toys

Long Island

Closed: December 28, 2019

Family/Kids

Frosty – BayWay

Long Island

Closed: January 5, 2020

Comedy

Fully Committed

Long Island

Closed: January 26, 2020

Family/Kids

The Magic of Alexo

Long Island

Closed: January 20, 2020

Musical

Disco Inferno

Long Island

Closed: February 16, 2020

Musical

Guys & Dolls

Long Island

Closed: March 15, 2020

Family/Kids

101 Dalmatians

Long Island

Closed: April 4, 2020

Comedy

Love, Sex and the I.R.S.

Long Island

Closed: April 11, 2020

Musical

We Will Rock You

Long Island

Closed: May 3, 2020

Family/Kids

Cinderella

Long Island

Closed: May 16, 2020

Drama

Driving Miss Daisy

Long Island

Closed: May 24, 2020

Musical

Curtains

Long Island

Closed: June 14, 2020

Concert/Event

Rock Country Nights: A Live Band Experience

Long Island

Closed: December 30, 2023