Watch Kelli O'Hara, Eva Noblezada Perform at MCC Theater's Miscast Gala

MCC Theater held its annual Miscast gala — a theater-industry mainstay that features Broadway's biggest stars performing songs from roles in which they would never be cast — on April 1. In addition to featuring Jennifer Nettles and Karen Olivo singing "All the Wasted Time" from Parade, the event featured Eva Noblezada singing "Go the Distance" from the Disney film Hercules…and, perhaps most unexpectedly, Kelli O'Hara tackling the Billy Flynn number "All I Care About" from Chicago, accompanied by members of the original cast of the long-running Broadway revival. Check out both performances below.