Explore Shows from this Story Musical The Fantasticks New York City Closed: June 4, 2017 Theater News Aaron Carter Chats TheaterMania talks with the pop star about his Off-Broadway role in The Fantasticks, his fans, and his upcoming EP. Brian Scott Lipton Tristan Fuge New York City February 21, 2012 Featured In This Story Musical The Fantasticks New York City Closed: June 4, 2017