SEARCH
Black Milk
REVIEW
Jenifer Lewis: Black Don't Crack

2012 NYMF Roundup #3

A scene from Le Cabaret Grimm
(Courtesy of the company)
A scene from Le Cabaret Grimm
(Courtesy of the company)
Le Cabaret Grimm, at 45th Street Theatre, opens with the giddy promise of magic. A red velvet curtain hangs mysteriously upstage as a corseted woman with a sultry voice welcomes us to the show while making her way down the aisle. She promises us adventures that will awaken hidden desires. Unfortunately, Veronique (played with commanding charm by Haley Selmon), to no fault of her own, cannot deliver on these promises.

The 90-minute musical is plagued with a generic book by Jason Slavick that fails to capture the enduring power of Grimm's classic tales, and a lackluster score by Cassandra Marsh that trudges up cookie cutter melodies of the most maudlin of Broadway shows and soft rock relics. Slavick's thin lyrics don't help in advancing the plot -- a princess who searches the globe for her prince -- and mostly feel like filler.

In the playbill, he writes of the show being a "punk cabaret" in the vein of Amanda Palmer. This is puzzling as the music and over-the-top dramatization couldn't be farther from punk ethos, but I couldn't help thinking of Palmer's superbly imaginative Evelyn, Evelyn that played off-Broadway a few seasons ago. Slavick and Marsh's show also features conjoined twins but the similarities end there. While Palmer's twins examine the nature of their identity, Slavick and Marsh's merely scream at each other in a shrill voice.

This lack of nuance seeps through the entire show but comes to a head in the penultimate number, "BFB," when the cast leads a reluctant audience to sing along to a song that features little more than the word "bitch." The creators seem to have taken "punk" to simply mean brash, and this is a disservice not only to the audience but to the talented cast trapped in this dreadful show.

-- Chris Kompanek



comments powered by Disqus

By providing information about entertainment and cultural events on this site, TheaterMania.com shall not be deemed to endorse,
recommend, approve and/or guarantee such events, or any facts, views, advice and/or information contained therein.

©1999-2013 TheaterMania.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use & Privacy Policy