Co-written by Renee Taylor and Joe Bologna, It Had To Be You! is the story of Theda Blau (Taylor), a struggling second-rate (B) movie actress and wannabe playwright desperately seeking love and success in New York. Vito Pignoli (Bologna) is a super successful television commercial producer. Theda meets Vito by auditioning for him and then convinces him to become her partner in dramaturgy and marriage… by holding him hostage in her apartment on a snowy Christmas Eve.