Family and faith are not always kosher. Joshua Harmon's acclaimed comedy asks questions about what you really choose to believe…when you're chosen. The patriarch of a Jewish family passes away, and his very different grandchildren gather together to relive, share, and remember. Liam is a declared atheist, Daphna has ferociously attached herself to every aspect of her heritage, and Jonah does his best to keep the peace. When Liam declares ownership over a cherished heirloom, a battle ignites of Old Testament proportions over what their family history truly means to each of them.