While The Muny did not pick up any Outstanding Production nods, its musical productions were well represented with acting nominations for Robert Westenberg, Catherine Brunell, Daniel Reichard, and Zoe Vonder Haar in My Fair Lady, Lewis J. Stadlen, Lee Roy Reams, and Angie Schworer in The Producers, and Eugene Fleming in My One and Only.

The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis picked up the majority of nominations (32) including for its productions of the plays Evie's Waltz, The Lieutenant of Inishmore, The Little Dog Laughed and Rabbit Hole, as well as the musicals Ella and Emma.

Other notable nominations included director Rob Ruggiero for both The Little Dog Laughed and Ella, and Tina Fabrique as Lead Actress in a Musical for Ella.