The show is about 6 gay men in a Fire Island share house. The main story centers on Randall who is in an "open" relationship with his boyfriend Timothy. Randall goes to tea, happy hour, and meets Jake; a younger good-looking man who is a romantic and in love at first sight with Randall. Randall must ultimately decide between staying with Timothy or taking a chance and going with Jake. In the share house is the newbie weekend guest, Antonio, a bodybuilder named Robby and the house mother, Donnie.