Explore Shows from this Story Musical Once On This Island North Jersey Closed: June 24, 2012 Video Feature VIDEO FEATURE: Once on This Island Lynn Ahrens, Darius De Haas, Adam Jacobs, Thomas Kail, Syesha Mercado, and Saycon Sengbloh preview the Paper Mill Playhouse’s new production of the beloved musical. Brian Scott Lipton Tristan Fuge North Jersey May 30, 2012 Featured In This Story Musical Once On This Island North Jersey Closed: June 24, 2012