Josh Grisetti, Nick Spangler, and Chip Zien also join the ensemble of the new comedy directed by David Hyde Pierce.
David Hyde Pierce directs the production, which originated at George Street Playhouse.
The performers replaced Laura Osnes and Harriet Harris earlier this year.
The classic musical played February 5-9.
Your first look at the latest New York revival of the classic musical.
Little Me with Christian Borle, The Most Happy Fella with Laura Benanti, and John Doyle's Irma La Douce are part of the newest season of the acclaimed concert musical series at New York City Center.
Drama Desk Award winner Rachel York will star opposite Borle as the object of his six characters' affections.
She'll take over the role of "Madame."