Tony Award nominees Laura Osnes and Santino Fontana, stars of Cinderella, took to the stage at Broadway supper club 54 Below on September 23 in a benefit concert titled Remember When...A Benefit Evening of Music and Dining. Hosted by New York Pops Musical Director Steven Reineke, the show supported The New York Pops Educational Programs at Ronald McDonald House New York and featured tunes from Annie Get Your Gun, Peter Pan, and It's a Bird…It's a Plane…It's Superman, among others.

Check out photos from the event in the gallery below.