Loving movies is easy. Loving people is hard. A relationship implodes one night in Brooklyn, NY, as a couple spends a post-coital evening discussing their love, obsession and hatred for film and each other. Attempting to cope with life off-screen, Johnny - a twenty-something womanizer - dispassionately announces his plans to move to LA, leaving his long-infatuated lover, Arden, and his roommate of five years, Plato, crushed. As the heated debating, movie quoting and beer throwing reaches a feverish climax, an unexpected visit from Johnny's latest conquest, Natalie - a bicoastal trust-fund debutante - threatens all hope for his new life.